used-test-audi-sq5-vs-porsche-macan-s-verdict

Audi

Porsche is best known as the quintessential sports car maker, but its line-up is increasingly diverse, interesting and successful, from its SUV family to the Panamera hatchback and shooting brake and, in time, a planned family of electric vehicles.

Whatever your choice, What Car?’s testers rate the cars highly; Porsche has an unusually high percentage of five and four-star cars.

Without exception, its sports cars are class leaders or among the class leaders, standing out for combining driving thrills with surprising luxury and comfort. Likewise, its SUVs are among the sharpest handling, as well as offering high levels of practicality and quality. Meanwhile, the Panamera is a true rival to the very best large executive saloons.

Porsche also sees itself as an electric car pioneer and has already enjoyed sales success with its plug-in hybrid range. Its first all-electric sports car is imminent, signalling the firm’s intent to stay relevant for many years to come.

PORSCHE

MACAN

<h3>Our verdict</h3>As we've explored, the Audi SQ5's diesel engine isn't badly shown up, performance-wise, by the Porsche Macan's petrol one. Couple that with praiseworthy economy and the notion of diesel power in a sports SUV makes decent sense. However, the SQ5 is unlikely to tempt you to take the scenic route to work just for the fun of it, while its rival will.The Macan positively encourages you to grab the keys and head out for a drive. In fact, even as a five-year-old used buy, it's the definitive blueprint for a sports SUV. Factor in that it holds its value better and remains pretty practical, it soon becomes clear that the Macan is the winner.

For all the latest reviews, advice and new car deals, sign up to the What Car? newsletter <a href="http://pages.haymarket.com/whatcar/wcar-form.html">here</a><hr /><h3>1st – Porsche Macan</h3>

For More fun to drive; smoother ride; holds its value brilliantly; sporty driving position Against Smaller boot; tighter rear seats; thirsty; pricier to buyWhat Car? says 4 stars out of 5

<h3 dir="ltr"><a href="https://www.whatcar.com/porsche/macan/4x4/used-review/n908">Read our full used Porsche Macan review &gt;&gt;</a></h3><h3 dir="ltr"><a href="https://www.whatcar.com/used-cars/porsche/macan?used=true&amp;nearlynew=true&amp;yearFrom=2019">Find a used Porsche Macan for sale &gt;&gt;</a></h3><hr /><h3 dir="ltr">2nd – Audi SQ5</h3>

For Roomier and slightly classier inside; more standard kit; better infotainment Against Less involving; noisier; engine note a bit artificial; heavier depreciationWhat Car? says 4 stars out of 5<h3 dir="ltr"><a href="https://www.whatcar.com/audi/q5/4x4/used-review/n889">Read our full used Audi Q5 review &gt;&gt;</a></h3><h3 dir="ltr"><a href="https://www.whatcar.com/used-cars/audi/q5?used=true&amp;nearlynew=true&amp;derivative.trim=sq5&amp;yearFrom=2019">Find a used Audi SQ5 for sale &gt;&gt;</a></h3><hr /><h3>Specifications: Audi SQ5 3.0 V6 TDI quattro</h3>

Engine 3.0-litre diesel Power 342bhp  Torque 516Ib ft  0-60mph 4.8sec Top speed 155mph Fuel economy 34.4mpg (WLTP) CO2 emissions 172g/km (NEDC)<hr /><h3>Specifications: Porsche Macan S 3.0 V6</h3>

Engine 3.0-litre petrol Power 349bhp  Torque 354Ib ft  0-60mph - 4.6sec Top speed 157mph Fuel economy 25.7mpg (WLTP) CO2 emissions -204g/km (NEDC)<hr /><h2 dir="ltr"><a href="https://www.whatcar.com/news/used-test-audi-sq5-vs-porsche-macan/n24571">&lt;&lt; Previous</a> | <a href="https://www.whatcar.com/best/best-used-large-suvs-for-less-than-pound20000/n23216">Read more: Best used large SUVs for less than £20,000 &gt;&gt;</a></h2>Page 4 of 4

<h3>Our verdict</h3>As we've explored, the Audi SQ5's diesel engine isn't badly shown up, performance-wise, by the Porsche Macan's petrol one. Couple that with praiseworthy economy and the notion of diesel power in a sports SUV makes decent sense. However, the SQ5 is unlikely to tempt you to take the scenic route to work just for the fun of it, while its rival will.

The Macan positively encourages you to grab the keys and head out for a drive. In fact, even as a five-year-old used buy, it's the definitive blueprint for a sports SUV. Factor in that it holds its value better and remains pretty practical, it soon becomes clear that the Macan is the winner. For all the latest reviews, advice and new car deals, sign up to the What Car? newsletter <a href="http://pages.haymarket.com/whatcar/wcar-form.html">here</a><hr /><h3>1st – Porsche Macan</h3>

For More fun to drive; smoother ride; holds its value brilliantly; sporty driving position Against Smaller boot; tighter rear seats; thirsty; pricier to buyWhat Car? says 4 stars out of 5<h3 dir="ltr"><a href="https://www.whatcar.com/porsche/macan/4x4/used-review/n908">Read our full used Porsche Macan review &gt;&gt;</a></h3><h3 dir="ltr"><a href="https://www.whatcar.com/used-cars/porsche/macan?used=true&amp;nearlynew=true&amp;yearFrom=2019">Find a used Porsche Macan for sale &gt;&gt;</a></h3><hr /><h3 dir="ltr">2nd – Audi SQ5</h3>

For Roomier and slightly classier inside; more standard kit; better infotainment Against Less involving; noisier; engine note a bit artificial; heavier depreciation

What Car? says 4 stars out of 5<h3 dir="ltr"><a href="https://www.whatcar.com/audi/q5/4x4/used-review/n889">Read our full used Audi Q5 review &gt;&gt;</a></h3><h3 dir="ltr"><a href="https://www.whatcar.com/used-cars/audi/q5?used=true&amp;nearlynew=true&amp;derivative.trim=sq5&amp;yearFrom=2019">Find a used Audi SQ5 for sale &gt;&gt;</a></h3><hr /><h3>Specifications: Audi SQ5 3.0 V6 TDI quattro</h3>

Used test: Audi SQ5 vs Porsche Macan S verdict

<h2>What we're looking for:</h2><ul><li>Plenty of space for all passengers</li> <li>Large boot with lots of clever storage solutions</li> <li>Good fuel economy and running costs</li> <li>All-round comfort</li> <li>High-quality interior finish</li></ul>

We define a large SUV as anything longer than 4.5 metres. These cars aren’t usually particularly cheap to buy or lease, so in return we expect a roomy cabin, a lengthy list of standard equipment and excellent cruising refinement.

A few models in this class are two-wheel drive, but the vast majority have four-wheel drive for at least a modicum of off-road ability.

Large SUV

These sporty SUVs offer thrilling performance, but does the Audi SQ5 or Porsche Macan make the superior used buy? 


Used test: Audi SQ5 vs Porsche Macan S verdict        

Audi is a brand that sets the standard for interior quality, and this, combined with its vast and ever-growing model line-up, has helped it become one of the ‘big three’ German prestige car makers, along with BMW and Mercedes-Benz.

The A3 hatchback, A4 executive saloon and Q7 SUV are all common - yet upmarket - sights on UK roads.

At least some of Audi's success over the past 30 years can be attributed to the growth in sales of vehicles with four-wheel drive; the company arguably led the way in bringing 4x4 technology into the mainstream, with its Quattro coupé in the early 1980s.

Today, most Audis are available with at least the option of four-wheel drive, while the list of SUVs from the brand includes the Q2, Q3, Q5 and Q7.

AUDI

In many ways, modern Bentleys offer the best of both worlds, blending traditional British craftsmanship with modern mechanicals developed with the help of the company’s owner, Volkswagen.

The Bentayga SUV, for example, is closely related to Audi’s brilliantly engineered Q7 (another VW Group car). Yet the Bentayga still feels every inch a Bentley, thanks to its hand-finished interior and sonorous V8 engine.

Other Bentleys you can buy today include the Flying Spur&nbsp;saloon&nbsp;and the Continental GT coupé and convertible.

BENTLEY

Munich-based BMW is most famous for its sports saloons, in particular the 3 Series and 5 Series. However, it actually builds almost every type of car imaginable: everything from two-seat convertibles to seven-seat MPVs.

The cheapest model in the BMW range is the 1 Series hatchback, which is a rival to the Audi A3, Mercedes-Benz A-Class and Volkswagen Golf. Meanwhile, at the other extreme is the M8&nbsp;grand tourer, which costs more than £120,000.

BMW was also quick to capitalise on the rise of the SUV and now has ten in its range: the X1, X2, X3, X4, X5, X6, X7 and XM, plus the electric iX3 and iX.

All of this makes it one of the big three German prestige brands, along with Audi and Mercedes-Benz.

Alpina has produced high-performance versions of BMW's range since the 1960s, and is now considered to be a manufacturer in its own right.

Whilst it cars are typically fast, and are often considered alternatives to BMW's M models, they are typically more comfortable with engines that provide a more relaxed power delivery.

Its models have similar naming conventions to the equivalent BMW: the B3 is based on the BMW 3 Series and the B4 Gran Coupé started life as a 4 Series Gran Coupé, for example.

BMW ALPINA

The sportiest Seats have long used the&nbsp;Cupra name, but it's now been turned into a standalone sub-brand, in much the same way as Fiat's sportiest models are badged as Abarths.

Like Abarth, some of Cupra's models including the Ateca and Leon are extensively reworked Seats, but models such as the Born and Formentor are exclusive to Cupra.

Whilst Cupras are closely related to equivalent models from Seat and Volkswagen, they are generally tuned to provide a more engaging driving experience.

CUPRA

One of the world’s most famous brands and an integral part of the Formula 1 grid since the first championship in 1950, Ferrari fully lives up to its exalted reputation, producing some of the best sports cars money can buy.

Its entry-level model (although that term hardly seems appropriate) is the Portofino convertible, which is powered by a twin-turbo V8 and capable of blasting from 0-62mph in 3.5sec.

Then further up the range you find the mid-engined 488s, in coupé and Spider forms, and two GT cars: the GTC4 Lusso and the appropriately named 812 Superfast, a V12 monster that can hit 211mph.

FERRARI

Ford builds some of the most popular cars in the UK, including the Fiesta and Focus hatchbacks.

This success is partly down to longevity and the fact that there’s a Ford dealer around every corner. However, it’s also because Fords tend to offer good value and be among the best cars in their respective classes to drive.

The company’s huge range also helps; it offers everything from the small – but surprisingly practical – Ka+ to the large and lavishly equipped Edge SUV.

Meanwhile, other highlights of the range include the S-Max and Galaxy people carriers, the Mondeo executive car and the Ranger pick-up.

FORD

GENESIS

Hyundai has transformed itself from a maker of oddball hatchbacks that sold in small numbers in the UK, to a major rival to the likes of Ford, Vauxhall and Volkswagen.

The Korean firm’s Ioniq Hybrid is particularly impressive, having beaten the trend-setting Toyota Prius when we tested the cars back to back.

Meanwhile, at the extremes of the Hyundai range you find the tiny i10 city car – a four-time What Car? award winner – and the stylish yet family-friendly Santa Fe SUV.

As a bonus, all of these cars come with the reassurance of a five-year, unlimited-mileage warranty, whereas most of Hyundai’s rivals offer only three years and 60,000 miles of cover.

HYUNDAI

INEOS

Jeep only makes SUVs, but it has plenty of them for you to choose from. So, whether you want something rugged enough to ford streams and climb mountains, or a more luxurious and family-friendly car, it has something to suit you.

Despite its all-American image, Jeep is actually owned by Fiat, meaning Jeeps often share parts with cars from the Italian giant; the entry-level Renegade, for example, has plenty in common with Fiat’s 500X.

However, perhaps the most widely recognised Jeep is the Wrangler, a model that has a dedicated fan base and which closely resembles the original Jeep which saw service in World War 2.

The brand’s future plans include new small and large SUVs, plus the introduction of fully electric models.

JEEP

Buyers seeking value for money should have Kia towards the top of their shopping list.

Although once a niche brand in the UK, today Kia outsells many more established brands, helped by its market-leading seven-year warranty and a strong reputation for reliability; in fact, Kia regularly finishes towards the top of our reliability surveys.

There are plenty of models to choose from, too, ranging from the small Picanto city car to the Ceed family hatchback and the Sorento large SUV. The Picanto was the first Kia to win its class at the What Car? Car of the Year awards.

Land Rover is synonymous with SUVs, and especially with the Defender – the rugged runabout that has seen service in war zones across the world, but also as part of the Queen’s personal garage.

If off-road prowess is one of Land Rover’s core values, though, the other is luxury. Indeed, the Range Rover, Range Rover Sport and Range Rover Velar are among the best luxury SUVs you can buy.

The Discovery, meanwhile, is a practical rival for the Audi Q7 and BMW X5, while the stylish Evoque (which is available as a three-door convertible as well as a traditional SUV) goes head to head with Audi’s Q3 and BMW’s X1.

In the coming years, we’ll see a new road-biased ‘Road Rover’ as well as an all-new Defender.

LAND ROVER

In the same way that Infiniti acts as Nissan’s premium arm, Lexus has a similar tie-in with Toyota. And since most of Toyota’s models are offered as hybrids, it’s no surprise to see the same from Lexus, although there are some traditional petrol engines, too.

The brand focuses heavily on SUVs – namely the NX and RX – but also has the CT hatchback, ES executive saloon and LS luxury car among its portfolio. More small and large SUVs are expected in the future.

Like Toyota, Lexus has built a very strong reputation for reliability and regularly finishes very close to the top of our annual Reliability Survey.

LEXUS

Mazda can be summed up in a single word: bold. Not only do its cars generally look like nothing else on the market, but it’s also invested heavily in innovative engine technology.

So, while many car makers have moved to smaller turbocharged engines, Mazda instead offers larger motors that are still efficient. For example, the entry-level petrol option in the Mazda 3 is a 2.0-litre unit –&nbsp;far larger than what you’ll find in most rivals – but it remains very clean.

Highlights of Mazda’s line-up include the MX-5 sports car, which has won our Convertible of the Year Award multiple times, and the CX-5 large SUV, which was named as our inaugural best car for dog owners.

MAZDA

Mercedes’ line-up is vast – ranging from the A-Class family hatchback through to staple saloons such as the C-Class and E-Class, and onwards towards multiple SUVs, luxury saloons and even sports cars. Coupés and convertibles are thrown into the mix as well.

As one of the ‘big three’ German brands, Mercedes most often finds itself competing with Audi and BMW but more recently has found itself fending off Jaguar and Volvo, too.

Mercedes models are known for comfort. One example of this is the E-Class, because while the Audi A6 has a plusher interior and the BMW 5 Series handles better, the E-Class is probably the most comfortable for a long motorway journey.

MERCEDES-BENZ

Nissan turned up early to the SUV party, with its Qashqai paving the way for the countless models we see today. The Qashqai continues to sell in big numbers in the UK, too, and was also our overall Car of the Year in 2014.

Don’t think Nissan is just about SUVs, though. As well as the Qashqai, the smaller Juke and the larger X-Trail, the Japanese brand has the Micra hatchback, GT-R sports car and Navara pick-up truck.

Nissan was also one of the first big car makers to launch a fully electric car, with its latest Leaf being one of the best on the market.

Despite being based in Japan, Nissan has long committed to building cars in the UK, making several of its best-selling models at a huge factory in Sunderland.

NISSAN

OMODA

When it comes to making a statement about how successful you are, there is no brand that shouts “I’ve made it!” more emphatically than Rolls-Royce.

If that’s all you want from your car, look no further. The firm has expanded its range in recent years, with the top-of-the-range Phantom saloon being joined by the Cullinan SUV, and other models including the Wraith and Ghost.

Whichever way you go, if you have to ask how much it costs, the chances are you can’t afford it. And, even then, the base price is unlikely to be what you end up spending, such is the list of alluring options on offer.

It’s also a moot point whether the cars themselves – rather than the image they portray – represents the very best way to spend your money. What Car?’s testers rate all of them positively but reckon that – if you’re buying with your head rather than your heart – there are other cars that you should also consider.

ROLLS-ROYCE

One of the greatest success stories in the car world of recent decades is Skoda’s rise to become a hugely credible mainstream maker of good-value, good-sense cars.

Central to that success has been its place within the VW Group, alongside the Volkswagen brand itself, plus the likes of Seat and Audi. That has given it access to exactly the same underpinnings for its cars as the other brands, and it has complemented this by adding its own developments, from the way the cars drive and ride through to the features they have and the pricing.

The result is a range that extends from a city car to a large executive saloon, with family and large seven-seat SUVs too. There’s a wide variety of petrol and diesel engines, all of which are competitive for the class.

As a result, Skoda has a range of cars that is almost entirely class-leading or among the class leaders, and it has enjoyed long-time success at the What Car? Awards as a result.

SKODA

Once best known for its flame-spitting, rally-bred Imprezas, Subaru’s focus now is on cars that will appeal to a far wider audience, and especially one that values go-anywhere ability and no-nonsense values above all others.

The result is a mixed bag of offerings, none of which rise beyond being average in their class but most of which have facets that make them stand out from their rivals. Core to its range are the Forester and Outback SUVs, while the Levorg is a more conventional estate.

At other extremes, there’s also the BRZ, an entertaining coupé that is let down by its price and resale values, and of course the Impreza, which comes in a variety of forms, including a hot model.

SUBARU

Suzuki is well known as a motorcycle manufacturer, but the car brand has been enjoying decent success in recent years, thanks to a line-up of neat, well-equipped and keenly priced models.

Its expertise focuses on smaller cars, although its high-riding SUV range is also hugely credible, especially the Ignis and Vitara, which are both rated highly by What Car?’s testers and which have enjoyed success at the What Car? Awards as a result.

Well priced, decent to drive and full of useful tech, Suzuki’s cars also generally stand out for delivering good fuel economy. The Ignis, Celerio and Baleno have all stood head and shoulders above the competition during our True MPG testing.

SUZUKI

Toyota is a company undergoing a quiet revolution, as it works hard to replace its sensible but somewhat bland reputation with one for being a bit more daring, in areas such as the styling of its cars and its enthusiastic leadership of cutting-edge technology, such as hybrid systems.

That process seems to be working for buyers, with the hugely popular and striking-looking C-HR SUV in particular attracting a great deal of interest. The latest version of the hybrid Prius is also rated highly by What Car?; it’s the first Prius to go on sale that our testers have felt can truly compete all round with existing petrol or diesel rivals.

However, it’s worth noting that this period of transition is also a work in progress, and that many of the firm’s cars are still rated as being no more than average among class rivals by our testers.

TOYOTA

The VW Group famously spends more money on research and development than any rival – and as a result, perhaps it should be no surprise that our testers rate its cars so consistently highly.

The fact that many of those cars use the same underpinnings also helps, because it means that if they get it right once, they have the foundations to keep on getting it right.

However, the Volkswagen brand faces plenty of tough competition, often from within, because the rapidly rising Seat and Skoda brands that are also part of the group have access to the same technology.

VOLKSWAGEN

Volvo is now a true rival to the likes of Audi, BMW, Jaguar and Mercedes-Benz, offering an alternative take on premium executive cars to a rapidly growing fanbase.

After a string of strong launches – notably with the Mk2 XC90 and XC60 SUVs – it struck gold in early 2018 when it launched its smallest SUV, the XC40. When our testers compared the car with its rivals, they concluded that it was the best launch of the previous 12 months, earning it our coveted overall Car of the Year Award.

The good news is that, like many car makers, Volvo now uses the same structure underneath most of its cars – so if they get it right on one model, it usually bodes well for the rest. That’s the case here, with Volvo’s subsequent saloon and estate launches complementing the SUVs and making for a generally extremely appealing line-up.

VOLVO

MACAN ELECTRIC ESTATE

Unlike most SUVs, the Porsche Macan is designed to appeal to keen drivers. In fact, it's aimed at buyers who've outgrown a Cayman but don’t want to give up the Porsche badge or the driving enjoyment that goes with it. Think of it as the best of both worlds – a car that's fun but also practical.

Since its introduction almost a decade ago, the Porsche Macan has become a huge seller for its maker. It's a smaller and more affordable option than the Stuttgart brand's other SUV, the <a href="https://www.whatcar.com/porsche/cayenne/estate/review/n17375">Porsche Cayenne</a>.

There's no electric version yet and no <a href="https://www.whatcar.com/news/plug-in-hybrid-cars/n22743">plug-in hybrid</a> either, but the Macan is available with a choice of four or six-cylinder turbocharged petrol engines. There's also an all-electric version – see our <a href="https://www.whatcar.com/news/porsche-macan-electric-suv/n26387">Porsche Macan Electric review</a>.

While the Macan is getting rather long in the tooth, Porsche likes to fettle and hone its products over the course of their lives, and this model is no exception, with two major facelifts. The latest introduced tweaked exterior styling and a reworked interior with the aim of keeping the Macan competitive against rivals, namely the <a href="https://www.whatcar.com/audi/q5/4x4/review/n17278">Audi SQ5</a> and hot versions of the <a href="https://www.whatcar.com/jaguar/f-pace/estate/review/n17356">Jaguar F-Pace</a> and <a href="https://www.whatcar.com/mercedes-benz/glc/4x4/review/n17345">Mercedes GLC</a>.

So, is the Porsche Macan the <a href="https://www.whatcar.com/best/sports-suvs/n20200">best sports SUV</a> on sale today? Read on to find out...

The Macan is fantastic to drive with&nbsp;a classy interior but there&nbsp;are more practical options

Porsche Macan

<h2>What we're looking for:</h2><ul><li>Strong performance</li> <li>Precise, feelsome steering</li> <li>Agile, entertaining handling</li> <li>Reasonable ride comfort</li> <li>Smart and practical interior</li></ul>

Needing a&nbsp;practical load-lugger doesn't mean you need to scrimp on power and sporting prowess. In fact, most sporty manufacturers now have dedicated sports SUVs in their line-up with 0-62mph times to rival cars half their size.

NEW REVIEWS:

Used test: Audi SQ5 vs Porsche Macan S verdict

These sporty SUVs offer thrilling performance, but does the Audi SQ5 or Porsche Macan make the superior used buy?...

Our verdict

1st – Porsche Macan

Porsche Macan 3.0 TD V6 S PDK 4WD Euro 6 (s/s) 5dr

Porsche Macan 3.0 V6 S PDK 4WD Euro 6 (s/s) 5dr

Porsche Macan 3.0 TD V6 S PDK 4WD Euro 6 (s/s) 5dr

Read our full used Porsche Macan review >>

Find a used Porsche Macan for sale >>

2nd – Audi SQ5

Read our full used Audi Q5 review >>

Find a used Audi SQ5 for sale >>

Specifications: Audi SQ5 3.0 V6 TDI quattro

Specifications: Porsche Macan S 3.0 V6

<< Previous | Read more: Best used large SUVs for less than £20,000 >>

Used test: Audi Q5 vs Porsche Macan vs Volvo XC60 interiors

Used test: Audi SQ5 vs Porsche Macan S interiors

Used test: Audi Q5 vs Porsche Macan vs Volvo XC60

Used test: Audi Q5 vs Porsche Macan vs Volvo XC60 verdict

Used cars for sale

Quick search

Tools & services

Legal bits

Information